How to Assume the Best in Others (A Lost Art Every Leader Needs)

Quick question: when someone forgets to reply to your email or cuts you off in traffic, what’s the first story you tell yourself?

It happens in marriages. It happens in businesses. It happens in churches. It happens all the time…every day.

Why We Assume the Worst

We see someone do something (or not do something) and we immediately begin to put a narrative together in our minds about why they did it (or didn’t do it).  We begin connecting dots to a story where we only have a very small portion of it. We find ourselves lost in our own imagination – making up a very compelling version of what we think is happening. This may be an ok exercise if it wasn’t for one small very important reason – the narratives we write are often false ones that are simply based on our own preferences, experiences, or environments.  In other words, we are adept at automatically assuming the worst about other people and organizations.  It’s our default. It’s gotten worse, in my opinion, because of our bent towards skepticism of others that’s been heightened by social media.  But, that’s an article for another day. A couple of ways that I’ve heard it said before are that “we accuse others and excuse ourselves” OR “we judge ourselves based off of our intentions and others based on their actions.”  In other words, we jump to conclusions about others with such judgement and lack of grace that we would never use on ourselves (and probably should).  We give ourselves grace in ways unlike we would extend to anyone else. But, I want to challenge us to something better.  I want to push you (and me, honestly) to re-find the lost art of assuming the best in others – always.  This is hard…I get it.  But, it is vitally important, especially today.  

What Assuming the Best Looks Like

Here are some examples that might help illustrate the point:
  • When I don’t empty out the dishwasher at home, it is easier for my wife to assume that I’m just lazy rather than assume that I must have been busy with the kids and I didn’t have time.
  • In an organization that I once led, I went with a new, distributor for all of our janitorial needs.  The people in the organization assumed that I bought “cheaper” toilet paper because I was only concerned about the bottom line rather than assume that we switched because it was a better solution for us in other ways (and it was actually more expensive).
  • We see this happen all the time with a single news headline or one small piece of information. We read a few details and build an entire narrative around them…and then we treat our story like it’s the whole truth.
Those are just a few examples.  I’m sure you can think of others.  But, can I just ask you to do me a favor? The next time your spouse does something that gets on your nerves, rather than thinking that he/she just did it to annoy you, try assuming the best about them. The next time your company has to make the tough decision to downsize or lay off employees, try assuming the best about their intentions rather than assuming that they’re money-hungry and only care about the bottom line. The next time your church or your pastor does something that goes against your tradition or your preferences or doesn’t meet your expectations some how, assume that they are following God’s lead and trying to do their best to serve people rather than assume that they are operating from a place of selfish motives.

3 Questions to Ask Before You Assume the Worst

Ok, this is where it gets practical. Here’s what I try to ask myself when I feel that “they did it on purpose” story starting up.

What else could be true? Maybe they’re overwhelmed. Maybe they never saw my message. Maybe they’re dealing with something I know nothing about. If I can come up with two other explanations, I’ve already slowed down.

What would I want someone to assume about me right now? I know my own heart. I want people to give me the benefit of the doubt, so I owe them the same.

Have I asked them? This one is hard…but it works. A simple “Help me understand what happened” clears up more than a week of guessing.

The 30-Day Challenge

Can we all commit to this for at least the next 30 days?  I think if everyone committed to the principal of assuming the best in others, our world would immediately see an improvement and we would all reap the benefit of not having our actions scrutinized and criticized.  Let’s make the world a better place and assume the best!  Who’s with me?

When was the last time you assumed the worst about someone, and what turned out to be true? Comment below…

If you’re the one on the receiving end of the criticism, read How to Handle Criticism as a Leader. And if you need to say something hard, here’s how to have a difficult conversation at work.

Feeling stuck as a leader? Take my free 3-minute Next Level Self-Assessment to see where you’re strong and where you’re stuck. You’ll also get my free Action Plan and ebook, Leadership for the Rest of Us. Want to talk it through? Learn about coaching.

Curious how you lead the people around you? Try my free LeaderScore™. It takes about 10 minutes and looks at 8 areas of leadership.

Get new articles by email

Practical leadership help for leaders who are making a difference right where they are. Join and I'll also send you my free ebook, Leadership for the Rest of Us.

Free live workshop: Plan Your Next Level in 2027

Thursday, Dec 17, 7–8 PM ET, live on Microsoft Teams. One hour to get clear on where you're stuck and what your next step is. Free to attend.

How strong is your leadership?

Take LeaderScore™, the free 10-minute assessment. See your level across 8 areas of leadership and find the best place to start.

Get your LeaderScore

Similar Posts